I was browsing a list of 35 uber-hip church web sites
and was shocked to see our house of worship wasn't listed. Not because
the church is "so cool" - but because its site (like some of these I suspect) is almost
frustratingly hip. It's primarily Flash-driven (a pet peeve of mine as
a designer) and the links are too clever to be useful.
On the whole, the collection of church sites listed are, if you don't mind my saying so, almost irreverent. These aren't the churches your grandparents attend. (Well...maybe. But if that's so, your nana is a bit hipper than mine.) Today's mega churches have long since adopted the web and all things digital in the fight to save your soul - or at least to get you to the chapel on Saturday nights. Even if that means using impossibly hip navigation and video streaming so hip you'd swear you'd just logged on to a music video site.
But all of this coolness leads me to wonder, are our church sites too cool? Are we excluding would-be-attendees from attending service? Are we changing the message to meet the medium? Is it working? WWJD?
From personal experience I can tell you this, it was refreshing to attend our church for the first time. The pastor wore broken-in jeans, a vintage tee, slightly mussed hair and a cool blazer. The brochure used fonts that my inner graphic designer secretly loved (no Comic Sans! No Papyrus!). They served coffee - good coffee - at a coffee bar. They even had Splenda. There were massive movie screens in the auditorium and they fully used technology to deliver the message. I felt... I'll just say it. Comfortable. I felt like I belonged. I felt like I wasn't being judged (at least not that day). And yet... there I was in my own distressed designer jeans, cool vintage tee and slightly mussed hair. Hey... wait a second.
So I suppose these super-hip site designs are just a sign of the times. And clearly attendees like myself love the coffee, the blogs, the buzz, the stadium seating, the cool fonts.... but do these edgy designs put off people like my parents? My grandparents? Are these sites, the churches themselves, the general design of the experience too cool? I'm wondering.... am I specifically the target demographic, to the exclusion of those older than myself? Does edgy site design discriminate on the basis of age? Does it prevent them from even walking in the door to hear the message? Can a simple grunge filter and custom font keep someone from driving to the church on Sunday morning (much less the way cooler Saturday night services)? Will we go so far to be inclusive that we actually become exclusive?
If you yourself go - or would refuse to go - to a church with a site (and matching brochures, natch) this cool, I'd love to hear your thoughts on how design plays a role in the message. As a designer with a passion for all things graphic and well styled, I'm completely biased. I like the holy jeans/holy message combination. But my Nana would probably never step a well-heeled foot in the door of my church.
